(11-24-2013 06:20 AM)DarianFrey Wrote: I've been learning about investing and stocks this year.
Right now, I'm halfway through Antifragile by Nassim Taleb. It's a great book and presents many interesting concepts. It made me start to ponder how an antifragile portfolio would look.
And, not gonna lie, reading the Yellen article on RoK has got me pretty scared about the money I've already put into stocks.
I know there are some market-savvy individuals here. How are you hedging against a crash? Is there an antifragile way to invest in today's market?
(11-24-2013 12:34 PM)WestIndianArchie Wrote: Taleb lays out his asset allocation practice in both books. 90% in cash/treasury notes, and 10% betting against the herd. That is it.
(11-24-2013 06:20 AM)DarianFrey Wrote: I know there are some market-savvy individuals here. How are you hedging against a crash? Is there an antifragile way to invest in today's market?
(11-24-2013 01:26 PM)Steve9 Wrote: In this video interview recorded after Antifragile was published, Taleb says he owns stocks, property, land and is selling his gold
(11-24-2013 06:52 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote:(11-24-2013 01:26 PM)Steve9 Wrote: In this video interview recorded after Antifragile was published, Taleb says he owns stocks, property, land and is selling his gold
That interview made no sense whatsoever. He is deathly afraid of inflation, an increasing money supply, and even social unrest, but he is selling his gold? It sounds as if he does not understand the purpose of gold as a hedge and an insurance policy against everything that he identified as a financial threat.
It goes to show that having the intellectual capacity to analyze complex concepts does not translate into the ability to reap the rewards from actually placing them into practice. Even Nikola Tesla was a poor businessman.
Quote:And, not gonna lie, reading the Yellen article on RoK has got me pretty scared about the money I've already put into stocks
(11-24-2013 07:56 PM)j r Wrote:(11-24-2013 06:52 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote:(11-24-2013 01:26 PM)Steve9 Wrote: In this video interview recorded after Antifragile was published, Taleb says he owns stocks, property, land and is selling his gold
That interview made no sense whatsoever. He is deathly afraid of inflation, an increasing money supply, and even social unrest, but he is selling his gold? It sounds as if he does not understand the purpose of gold as a hedge and an insurance policy against everything that he identified as a financial threat.
It goes to show that having the intellectual capacity to analyze complex concepts does not translate into the ability to reap the rewards from actually placing them into practice. Even Nikola Tesla was a poor businessman.
What exactly is the purpose of gold as an insurance policy? I do economics for living and I can't figure it out.
(11-24-2013 11:13 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote: So, if he expects inflation, money printing, and social unrest, then why he is selling his gold? I doubt that anyone here can answer that question, but it is a question that anyone who agrees with Taleb and who would like to protect their wealth in a financial crisis would like to know. Food for thought.
(11-24-2013 08:51 PM)WestCoast Wrote: This was the biggest year i've ever seen in my career and yet people are trying to tell me the "economy is weak". If you can't find ways to make money in this economy you're living under a rock.
(11-25-2013 11:37 AM)thedude3737 Wrote: Worst case scenario and we get a major crash? Good. I've got about 20K I can buy into the market while it's rock bottom.
(11-25-2013 11:53 AM)Way Cool Jr Wrote:(11-25-2013 11:37 AM)thedude3737 Wrote: Worst case scenario and we get a major crash? Good. I've got about 20K I can buy into the market while it's rock bottom.
It's all good unless you are highly leveraged, if you go long in a bear market thinking the stock exchange is at the rock bottom you put yourself in a very dangerous position.
You might think that the market is at the bottom and then it falls another 15%, for example, soon after.
If you are buying without leverage you can just wait for the next bull market but if you use leverage you can get hurt quite quickly.
(11-25-2013 06:46 AM)j r Wrote:(11-24-2013 11:13 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote: So, if he expects inflation, money printing, and social unrest, then why he is selling his gold? I doubt that anyone here can answer that question, but it is a question that anyone who agrees with Taleb and who would like to protect their wealth in a financial crisis would like to know. Food for thought.
I just answered that question. Taleb likely thinks that gold is not a very good hedge against financial crisis and that it is over-priced because so many people buy gold thinking that it is. Selling gold is a way of betting against the herd.
Quote:Given Taleb’s conviction that overgrown banks and rampant money creation are badly destabilizing the financial system, it’s natural to think he would take refuge in gold, which is why a conference attendee asked him whether gold represents part of his stable-value portfolio ballast.
He answered that he used to believe in this role for gold. But now, he says, “It’s too neat a narrative, gold.” He seems to mean that gold owners believe too avidly in the inviolability of the metal, and have constructed too elaborate a reassuring story about why it must perform as expected.
“Central banks own gold,” he notes, as if that is a self-evident indictment. And: “Something that doubles [in value] in no time can’t be a real store of value.”
(11-25-2013 12:43 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote:(11-25-2013 06:46 AM)j r Wrote:(11-24-2013 11:13 PM)Tail Gunner Wrote: So, if he expects inflation, money printing, and social unrest, then why he is selling his gold? I doubt that anyone here can answer that question, but it is a question that anyone who agrees with Taleb and who would like to protect their wealth in a financial crisis would like to know. Food for thought.
I just answered that question. Taleb likely thinks that gold is not a very good hedge against financial crisis and that it is over-priced because so many people buy gold thinking that it is. Selling gold is a way of betting against the herd.
You did not answer the question at all. First, the herd does not own gold. Any small portion of the herd who did own it bought it between $ 1,500 and $ 1,900 -- and then capitulated in June when it dropped below $ 1,200. The herd only buys when a commodity is hot. They always buy at the wrong time. Gold is now at the end of a three year correction and is now finishing a complex bottoming process, having dropped in price from over $ 1,900 to less than $ 1,200.
Second, the price of gold has bottomed either January or February in something like nine of the last thirteen years. January and February is now right around the corner and also coincides with the end of a complex bottoming process. So, if anything, gold is now undervalued and within a month or two of a final bottom and a great buying opportunity.
You did touch upon what I would like to know. Yes, for some reason, Taleb likely thinks that gold is not a very good hedge against a financial crisis, which he is clearly expecting. But why?
____________________________________________
Damn. After I wrote this missive, I realized I should have just Googled for an answer. [insert palm to forehead here]
He appears somewhat coy in his answer, but here it is:
Quote:Given Taleb’s conviction that overgrown banks and rampant money creation are badly destabilizing the financial system, it’s natural to think he would take refuge in gold, which is why a conference attendee asked him whether gold represents part of his stable-value portfolio ballast.
He answered that he used to believe in this role for gold. But now, he says, “It’s too neat a narrative, gold.” He seems to mean that gold owners believe too avidly in the inviolability of the metal, and have constructed too elaborate a reassuring story about why it must perform as expected.
“Central banks own gold,” he notes, as if that is a self-evident indictment. And: “Something that doubles [in value] in no time can’t be a real store of value.”
So, he does not believe that gold is necessarily a poor investment if you expect a highly destabilized financial system. But he also does not trust gold to remain a constant store of value -- just as he does not trust equities, bonds, or derivatives. So, what does he trust?
But although I now understand his argument, I do not buy his point. Gold has always increased in value as currencies badly inflate and lose their purchasing power. The value of gold remains stable, but it takes more [insert name of currency here] to buy it because of the currency devaluation that occurs during inflation. That is economics 101. The value of gold remains stable while the value of the fiat currency implodes. The world's monetary system was based on that very idea until 1970.
So, in summary, Taleb believes that gold is not "‘anti-fragile" enough for the next financial crisis. Wow. That is a scary thought indeed.
http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/michael-s...16155.html
(11-25-2013 01:06 PM)j r Wrote: This is exactly what I said in my first post. Gold is not the effective hedge against financial collapse that some people think it is. Gold will likely always be valuable, but like any other commodity it's price is going to be a function of overall demand in the economy. If overall demand plummets, then the price of gold plummets as well.
(11-25-2013 01:55 PM)Sawyer Wrote: Taleb may believe gold is fragile because there is a possibility that it becomes a remnant of a disappearing world.
When things really go south, they're not going to go south for the elite. They'll be getting richer, trading via inside deals, jetting to exclusive enclaves. They will become more untouchable than ever. In this respect, holding ancient stores of value, and therefore ancient beliefs about the meaning of value, can be a negative mental anchor, and therefore fragile.
For those stuck to the old ways, who will remain in District 9, physical gold makes sense. If nothing else it will be valuable for trade: staples, bullets, housing.
Taleb believes gold is fragile because he believes the elite have the infrastructure to pull away this time, and he doesn't plan on trading gold for beans and shitting in the woods.