(12-22-2016 06:29 PM)vinman Wrote: (12-22-2016 07:39 AM)Dalaran1991 Wrote: I was thinking about all the cool techniques in Aikido/jujutsu that is a lot of fun to do, but is utterly useless or non-existent in real life. First thing came to my mind: Koshinage, or hip throw.
Its very fun to do and take, and teaches a lot of principles (body movement, positioning, etc) but seriously in what case can you use this in competition or self-defense? The guy must be an utter moron to leave his center exposed, or he must be bull charging you for this to be pulled off.
Whats more, the throw in itself isnt that effective. Even on hard concrete you are slamming his back on the ground, not his face, and though it hurts it will not incapacitate anyone. If you were in a position to do this, a knee to the face or head choke is way better.
Thoughts on this Kai and company?
I have to disagree, slightly. I have used hip throws, and modified throws to trip people before shit got to serious. Now some of the wrist lock and throws in Aikido, and Jiu Jitsu are some horse shit though. Like the Irimi Nage from the wrist grab.
Oh Vinman! You must not be black belt rank or higher in your style to have that opinion.
That throw is not useless! They teach it to you early so that you master the movements so that
they are supposed to teach you around black or higher, the advanced form of it.
That throw gets nastier when you add the "Invisible Weapon" component to it. Pressure points!
There are several on your neck and collar bone area (here is just a small example):
3 of these completely stop feeling in the legs, causing the opponent to immediately drop to the ground.
That is why this stuff is supposed to be gentle to execute. Doing that throw normally requires force and muscle to fully execute if the opponent is bigger. If the opponent pulls away hard, you are supposed to stop that throw mid-stride and switch to something else anyway. We always follow the path of least resistance.
Your instructors should know these things or should teach you when you are advanced enough. Unfortunately quite a few do not know themselves.
Typically once you hit black belt in JJ or whatever, either your teacher should teach you the advanced stuff, or you go to a higher Dan master or instructor within your school's affiliation, to learn it.
Or you can supplement it by training other styles that have it or with books/videos. Dr. Sang H Kim has a very very good book. He even has Dim Mak stuff in it.
Downsides to books and videos is that you really need to be advanced to understand the application use properly otherwise, it looks like magic, bullshit, or mumbo jumbo.
Even I cannot understand all of the things in his book, especially some of the Dim Mak stuff because I do not have a base in that or enough formal education on meridians and physiology. Some of the things I understand perfectly because of my JJ training had it in it to begin with. Some of those things are just repeat information for me, but it's a great book. It's not for beginners at all.
The Grand Master himself! Grandmaster George Kirby's book is incredible. Same deal with Dr. Kim's book. This is NOT for beginners and just like Kim's book, the stuff in here can be dangerous in the wrong hands.
Master Kirby shows you all the nasty hidden versions of the same ol basic JuJitsu throws and locks. I learned a lot from him, more than what I could from other teachers because he is a 10th Dan ranked master in Japanese JuJitsu. I bet if I could have traveled to California to train at his school when I was young (unless they have an age restriction because I was a teen), they would have taught me the stuff but that wasn't an option for me.
When you don't have high ranks around you, try to go later or supplement with books. If you are advanced (brown belt or higher) you won't struggle to understand how it works at all, but if you read it as a beginner, you will think it's bullshit. When you get older and have the financial means, you can travel and get private lessons from masters to firm up what you know or learn even more new tricks, which is what I did.